Agreed, that's why I think if we re-sign 2 of 3 then it will be Bowser & Ngakoue. Ngakoue is interesting because he didn't have a great year & lost snaps but also came in late too. He could sign a one-year deal or we may give him a longer contract too, just depends. It would be strange to break the bank for him when he didn't do a ton, but maybe it's because we know he came in late to our defense. Kinda risky either way you slice it but that's the hand we got. I would go for Ngakoue before Judon due to age alone--I think Judon has a major red flag there and I like him but he has boneheaded plays seemingly every year--like Jernigan-lite.
Bowser seems like a no brainer, but McPhee & Ward are great rotational pieces that should remain that. I think expecting either to be every down players is a mistake, hence why I agree that we need to keep 2 of 3 with Ferguson.
idk that you should buy into the lower snap counts too much - i think it's a combination of a few things - when he first came in bowser's snaps disappeared and as we brought bowser back in it brought everyone on the EDGE's snaps down
the other is that Ngakoue didnt play a lot of snaps vs the run (where that was possible) so didnt play a huge amount vs the titans - and i think the bills went hurry up a lot when they caught us with guys like BWill on the field so i think that kept him off the field vs the bills
and of course both of these games were just after he missed the bengals game because of injury
i think it's clear to me that if all things were equal then we'd be retaining Bowser and Judon - bowser feels like the no-brainer based on likely price and role
but in terms of ngakoue vs judon with context, judon's obviously older and might be more expensive to retain too which leans in ngakoue's favour albeit ngakoue has the name-brand
with judon i think too much is made out of 'bone-headed' - i think 2018 he developed that reputation and then 2019 and 2020 were confirmation bias - he has 1 or 2 plays a season maybe like that and iirc on of the notable ones this year was an absolutely awful call by the refs