Tom Pellisserro compiling the league's general thoughts on qbs - the section on Josh Rosen is interesting:
Rosen's interviews confirmed his intelligence -- smarts that some compare to Peyton Manning's. The consensus, though not unanimous, remains that he's the most talented passer in the draft. As one scout who has done a lot of work on Rosen texted me Monday night, the Browns "need to do extreme due diligence to make sure he's not the one." No, Rosen won't be a personality fit for every team, and I found it telling in asking around that scouts seem higher on him than coaches. "To me, he's Jay Cutler and Jeff George. I just can't get past that in my head," a quarterbacks coach said. "I think he's going to do whatever he wants to do. I don't think he's going to listen to anybody. He always thinks he has the better answer, has the better way. Yeah, his film is really good. I just don't think he's going to mesh well with your team and do the things that you want him to do." Compare that to this assessment from one executive with a strong college scouting background who spent time with Rosen: "Smart. Mature. He was different than I expected him to be. I was really impressed with him. I think he has the makeup to be a good pro. He needs to be in the right situation with the right coach, the right team, because he'll ask a ton of questions." Some will take that dichotomy to mean coaches are insecure and sensitive about being challenged. Or maybe, as the QB coach countered, it's simply not conducive to success for a player at a leadership position to act like the smartest guy in the room. Several team officials mentioned former UCLA coach Jim Mora's comments that Rosen "needs to be challenged intellectually so he doesn't get bored" as a red flag. "The thing that bothers me with him is the concept that football's not the priority," an offensive coordinator said. "That drives me nuts. Because that's like taking somebody that you're going to bank your next 12 to 15 years on, and also at the same time, you're going to have to convince that guy that football's the most important thing in his life." Said the first scout: "Talent-wise, he should go No. 1. But at that position, you've got to be a real guy and you've got to be humble and do all the right stuff, and yeah, I think he's learning how to do that. And I think he's smart enough to figure that out."
this stuff pisses me off - clearly to me it seems like the league are finding reasons to not like him - and i do think its telling that coaches seem more down on him than evaluators - its not like his teammates at UCLA didnt like him or anything so i dont understand why his leadership capabilities are really questioned
the idea that him thinking he has the better answer is a problem is inane and stupid - coaches should be wanting to incorporate the ideas of their qbs into the offence and the idea around rosen is that he's always going to want to know why and ask questions about the scheme and the decisions he makes - the idea that thats a problem is stupid - that's going to make him a better qb and better able to read and audible at the LoS pre-snap and read the defence and understand why the team is doing certain things in certain spots - that's the kind of thing that would make me want him more
and the idea that players wouldnt like him because he 'acts like the smartest guy in the room' is only a problem if he actually "acts" like the smartest guy in the room - maybe he is the smartest guy in the room - that isnt a problem when it comes to veteran qbs so why is it a problem with Rosen
and this idea that football might not be his priority also seems stupid - he doesnt need football and he doesnt need to go through this process when teams are questioning him - yet he still does...
he didnt need to stand in the pocket and take the hits he did and take the concussions he did and throw to the corps he did but he still did because he evidently loves the game
he doesnt need the game and that's never been an issue before - look at peyton, eli, brady, rodgers - these guys didnt need to play football but they're great because they love the game and work at it and play it anyway
and this idea that football needs to be the number 1 thing in the life of a football player is a little weird too - outside interests ground you, family grounds you etc. that's not an issue for virtually every other player in the NFL - yes there are some who absolutely live and breathe football even during their time off but there are a majority of players who find other things to do and take other interests and build families and that's not a problem as long as they are committed but why does Rosen need "convincing" that football is the number 1 thing in his life - there's this idea that being intelligent automatically makes you incompatible with football and that because he has opinions on stuff outside of football that he's not focussed or committed - that's just stupid - people think about stuff and read about stuff all the time - id much rather a guy who thought about stuff intelligently than a guy who believes the earth is flat or dinosaurs never existed
rant over
TL;DR - for once i think the media is right and coaches (and scouts) are over reacting to absolutely nothing with regards to Josh Rosen - he's the best qb in the draft and he shouldnt be docked points because some coaches apparently have an inferiority complex over their intelligence with regards to being in the same room as him