I think you put him in a tier or two above me. I think AJ is borderline top tier if not the top of the 2nd tier.
AJ didn’t need to do anything during Saquon’s historic run last year, and last year they arguably had the worst OC.
Meanwhile we point to Zay last year, and yes he was great, but you also had Bateman and Likely out a majority of the season. Plus add in the fact Monken couldn’t utilize his WRs to their strengths.
My list would look closer to this, in no order besides tier:
Tier 1: JJ, Chase, JSN, Nacua, Nabers
Tier 2: Brown, Lamb, St. Brown, London, Collins, Pickens, McMillan, Pierce
Tier 3: Higgins, Waddle, Flowers, Smith, DK, Thomas, McLaurin, Addison, Sutton, Moore
At best Zay may be 14th, but I could see an argument for the other guys in that tier above him. He’s more like 14-20.