JoeyFlex5
Hall of Famer
I think the Humphrey vs peters debate is based on 2 things: popular opinion and preference. Watching Ed reeds entire career I just have a soft spot for that kind of player, he is just the smartest and most skilled player out there and plays with supreme confidence, he’s just a rare type of player and that skill set I believe will always work for him as long as he’s allowed to play to his strengths, and his impact may not be as consistently big as Humphreys as far as tangible production, but what else he provides is huge and when he does make that impact play, it’s big time. He’s an opportunist and he comes through in the clutch due to his film study and just innate understanding of what offenses are trying to do, Humphrey has some of that too but it’s very limited compared to peters, when the play is in front of him he’s as good as anyone in the league at any position of coming down for the stop, but peters has eyes on all sides of his head and can see out of all of them better than anyone out there can see from their 2. He doesn’t lock down a man, he locks down sections of the field, and if you complete one on him, or even near him, think twice before you try it again because odds are he’s already figured out how to pick the next one, and ANY mistake made in his area, he’s coming away with one, he’s just the most opportunistic player we’ve had in a very long time.we miss his iq and communication on the backend a ton - just the confidence and intelligence with at-snap or even post-snap adjustments and communication was excellent and enabled us to be so efficient on the backend
humphrey's the better pure man cover corner, but peters adds an element of threat that when you throw it towards his side of the field you're taking a risk and that weighs on a quarterback's mind
ill be really frustrated if he's not on this team in 2022 - ill understand if that's the last year he's here albeit ill likely be disappointed - but there's absolutely no reason to get rid of him for the 2022 season