I’m wondering if the criticism stems from the extremely limited film/videos on him. He might’ve had a couple bad games which happens to every player out there (to varying degrees obviously). So maybe the issues aren’t as bad as let on; maybe it’s just a bit of inconsistency
his movement skills are excellent so it’s unsurprising - he’s super inconsistent especially with his pedal and some of his press technique but theres no denying the movement skills, the physical traits and the ball skills