Sure... if healthy. Aaron Rodgers on the Ravens team that played the last month of the season has zero shot of being a contender.
If there's one thing we know about Rodgers, it's Rodgers + bad Oline = not beating good teams.
You put Rodgers on a team with a below average Oline and a defense that's in the bottom 5 in passing, and you're dead weight. He's had WAY more talent on his rosters the last few years and hasn't made it to the SB.
On Cleveland, he does very well. On Denver, he does very well.
That's my whole point. The entire basis for putting up Tomlin as coach of the year is based on Ben sucking. If they upgrade the QB, that roster competes extremely well in the AFC. I put Rodgers on the Jags, Jets, Texans, they're not competing to do anything.