This is all numbers over watching. BSteve has had a far superior season than Marlon and the numbers would tell you otherwise.
Not a playoff choker, but If he loses to another less talented team in the playoff might be time to pack it up
almost every great coach road the coat tails of a franchise signal caller.
I mean I don't think there was ever a single question that this would be what would happen once he signed. 0 trust in Melvin. Owen Wright is a quintessential JAG. Dalvin may not play much but he was clearly a better RB3 option than the other in house ones.
But that's the point. He wasn't available. That's a fair criticism. He's earned that criticism. Inability to be on the football field during critical stages of a season is a bad thing, not a good thing.
And I'm fine with the idea that people can evaluate QBs in the regular season. It's a bigger sample size, and you are correct that if a QB plays like shit, on average, for 17 weeks, there's a good chance he won't be in the playoffs anyway, so there's no point in discussing playoff record.
Who are your top 5 qbs? if its based off playoffs succees only , yes lamar is 1-3, his 1st playoff game didn't harbaugh admit to not opening the playbook til later in the game? '19 wasn't on him that was a team blunder and that's on the coach, only game that was on him was the bills who were on a hot streak
back in 2020 we lost 2 friends to covid. One was a neighbor and the other was a friends mother. We knew one person on a vent for 8 weeks and she survived but she's now living in an assisted living facility for the rest of her life and she's mid 50s. Another one was a friend of my wifes in Massachusettes on a vent for 4 weeks. Yeah, we don't take covid lightly . We have both had it once and luckily it wasn't bad.
Playoff success matters in the context of how you compare in totality in historical context. If you want to be considered among the greatest QBs ever, you better have at least substantial postseason success. You don't need 3-4 rings to be in that group, but you need to have at least proven you can beat good teams, in the playoffs, over an extended period of time. People can talk about how he's got a short sample size, and right now, that's true. But when does it not become true? What's the arbitrary line of demarcation where a QB has enough playoff games on his resume that it becomes a critical part of his evaluation? 5 games? 10 games? I don't know the answer, and I promise nobody else will give that answer either. They'll just pick whatever number matches with the narrative they seek.
I'd agree with that list if you're talking super bowl era. Other than that there are other qbs that could be brought into the equation. Of course you do have an etc... I know you say you lean more towards the modern QB, but Sammy Baugh is one of the greatest players of all time. Think he deserves to be on any persons list.
I'm not sure we stop the rotation as we want to keep them as healthy as possible throughout this stretch. Moses is still dealing with a labrum tear, but the both have looked a bit better.
Oh I agree got to start racking playoff suceess at this point with 2 mvps it's no longer acceptable to have one playoff win, the 1-3 record would need context though I do agree he didn't play up to par in those games but the only game where he was the reason they lost was the bills game. He now has a modern offensive coordinator, I'm expecting different results
