Hahaha that's great that disagree. This is such a subjective and squishy subject. That being said as I look back on my list I think the criticism of Tom Brady is overwhelmingly the most fair one. He's gotta be much lower.
I still think Hurts is legitimately not a good QB so we'll disagree on that one.
Jones and Tannehill are all the way at the bottom of that tier and if you bumped them down a few spots I wouldn't be all that upset with that.
Watson I think will continue to be very average at best next year. Maybe he'll prove me wrong but I don't buy it.
I think Stafford might be totally cooked. Jimmy G is constantly being attempted to improve on and is just not that good.
For me...
1. I don't know what more people need to see from Hurts. Like he's not Burrow or Mahomes as a passer, but there aren't 10 guys in this league I'd take over him. I think its borderline impossible to come up with an argument where you're low on Hurts but high on Lamar or Kyler. Like that doesn't make any sense to me.
I think the anti-Hurts camp is purely a productive of thinking he has everything anybody would ever need to be a successful QB (great play calling, elite Oline, high end weapons), and that's true. The problem is that's kind of how modern NFL QB play works anyway, because there really aren't great QBs out here winning in the playoffs without having at least 1-2 of those things, if not more.
2. I'm puzzled by people who think Dak and Cousins are in a group above guys like Stafford, Jimmy G or Watson. The latter group wins more. They've advanced further. They have far, far, far more upside in my opinion. Right coach, good weapons, they win everywhere.
I know exactly what I'm getting from Cousins and Dak. I'm getting solid regular season QBs who mix up huge games with total shit shows, and bow out of the playoffs before the Conf Championship game on pretty much an annual basis.
And both have a lot of quality players to throw to. Some have worse coaching than others, but also complain about incomplete rosters, when they're making a ton of money already. That's what paying great QB money to not great QBs looks like.
There's a list of QBs in this league that I think are special:
Mahomes
Allen
Burrow
Herbert
Hurts
Lamar
Rodgers
And I'd put Watson and Lawrence just outside that group but likely should be in it (just need to see another year).
If you don't have one of those guys, I think you need everything else to go your way to win in this league (high end coach, lots of weaons, solid Oline).