Jimmy is 100% a hit if you aren’t accounting for injuries. I mean he did say Luck was a hit for the Colts so he wasn’t really consistent with his analysis in regards to injuries. If Luck is a hit then so is Jimmy.
also he well undersold how good jimmy is - he said he'd been a decent starter with an uptick in production later in his career - but that undervalues him - he's been a top corner in the league for the last 4 years or so despite the injuries - that sounds like a hit to me