ill quibble with some of these e.g. on lasley and scott where how can you make a decision on whether or not they are good or not if they havent played a down of football yet or with Seiler or Chris Board who've hardly played at all on defence either
would be very interested in how you cut it down to 53 though
Lasley made the roster and he is a better route runner than Scott. I'll reevaluate after the pre-season games.
Sieler is very good athlete, but he needed a lot of reps and time to get used to the NFL level. He wasn't ready last season. Board played in the bills game and was in on 2-3 snaps and he missed his assignment in at least 1 one of those snaps which occured after the Bills game and I liked the play of other UDFA LBs better in the 2017 pre season. But this is likely to change after all these positive reports coming out of OTAs
Qbs(2): Jackson, Griffin
RB(4): Ingram, Dixon, Hill, Edwards
TE(3): Boyle, Andrews, Hurst
WR(5):Snead, Moore, Roberts, Brown, Boykin
OT(3): Stanley, Brown Jr, Senat
OG(4): Yanda, Powers, Bozeman, best UDFA
C(1): Skura
Edge(5):Judon, Williams, McPhee, Ray, Ferguson
DL(7): Pierce, Williams, Henry, Wormley, Sieler, Mack, Willis
LB(4): Onwuasor, Levine, Young, Board
CB(5): Humphrey, Smith, Carr, Averett, Marshall
Nickel(2): Young, Jones
FS(1): Thomas III
SS(3): Jefferson, Clark, Elliott
S.T.(3): Tucker, Koch, Cox
Injuries are going to certainly change this. 7 DL guys is obvioulsy too crowded, but they're all too talented to cut one of them, but then again injuries are going to factor in. I could also see DeCosta trading one or two guys (e.g. Canady). Bubble guys are:
3 WR Lasley, Wesley, Scott
1 Edge/off-ball LB Bowser
Long-shots:
Edge: Markus Jones
WR: Sean Modster
TE: Charles Scarff