This is obviously nonsense and I'm just asking for fun. Imagine Lamar has like a 15 or so tear career where he's pretty dominant like we've seen. He wins some playoff games but never gets a Superbowl. In that scenario, do you think he could make it into the HoF? If you think no, how many Superbowls do you think it would take?
winning a superbowl as a QB doesnt seem crucial to getting in albeit it might soon become important that way
- dan fouts never even reached a superbowl let alone won one
- jim kelly went to 4 superbowls but lost all 4
- dan marino never won one either
- Warren Moon never won one as a player either (did technically win one as a broadcaster for the seahawks in 2014 though lol)
- Fran Tarkenton never won a superbowl
phillip rivers might be a good test of that when he retires though
but so far it seems not important to win a superbowl at all - and there are a number of notable QBs who have only won one also...
i think when thinking about superbowl QBs you have to ask - could this person be regarded as so good at what they do that you can't tell the story of their era of football without mentioning them frequently and often
I obviously hope we win at least 1 superbowl (and hopefully more but let's not get ahead of ourselves) with Lamar at the helm but we're primed for a potentially league and sport-defining rivalry between mahomes and Lamar that could mean both of them make it to the HOF even if Lamar never won a superbowl during that period
that being said i find it hard to believe that if lamar does play that well that we would never win one
it would be hard to justify not including him in the HOF if he has multiple regular seasons that look anything like 2019 (or like how 2020 has started for him)