Could not agree more about Smith. He gave up on the attempt before it even landed in his vicinity. That being said, I am somewhat uncertain whether it qualifies as a good decision. My issue with the decision and subsequent throw stems from the following. The defensive scheme was fairly straight forward (
Link). They broke the huddle in a Quarter package; the defensive front is somewhat exotic with the four man rush consisting of an RE, an LE a MIKE, and a WILL. The latter two blitz head up, Chandler Jones waits for the LBs to engage in order to attempt a (soft) inside stunt. It's single-high with man coverage across the board. Devin McCourty is on the SRiWR, Patrick Chung is on the SRoWR, Tavon Young is the SS, who immediately doubles on Owen Daniels, who's running a post route. Here is where my issue begins. Duron Harmon begins as the single-high FS, exactly 15 yards off the LOS (
Link). Harmon drops back off of the snap while cheating to the left, and before Flacco is even finished with his three step drop, Harmon is now at 20 yards off of the LOS (
Link), having already advanced diagonally towards Smith, who'd be the only receiver on the left side of the hash at the time of the throw (
Link). The direction Harmon takes came as no surprise given that they were rolling a safety towards Smith through the better part of the night. This is something Chris Collinsworth made mention of as well. Flacco's eyes don't leave the left side, he takes one hop, and makes a somewhat off-balance throw while moving laterally to his left, and the ball lands on the inside shoulder, arguably several yards of the preferred window. Now I am right there with you with regards to the finish. It's almost unreal how quickly Smith abandons tracking the football in lieu of a woeful attempt at tackling Harmon before he even has his hands on the ball (
Link). Given where the ball landed, it would've been somewhat difficult but certainly not unfeasible for Smith to at least turn his head and attempt to corral the ball. As you've pointed out, he may have even come away with a score had he bodied up Harmon. Ultimately, I feel that the sourness towards Smith is certainly justified. But I thought that the read itself had numerous red flags. You have an FS with a 10+ yard lead on your only deep WR as you're about to wind up for the throw. Daniels is the only player moving towards the left hash, and he's blanketed by two safeties, so there no threat to force said FS to break off underneath, and the rolling safety was a staple concept that you've seen throughout the game. It's a ballsy move to make without stepping into throw or looking off the safety prior to the opposite side. In my eyes, it would at best be categorized as risky. Personally, with two LBs on the ground and Marlon Moore leading his CB away from the left, I don't know that it needed to be rushed. That's just me though.