BloodRaven
MVP
The term rampaging may overstate Ridley's performances to an extent. After a strong start, he amassed 547 yards on 140 carries in the last 8 games. An impressive TD total with 7, but the 3.9 YPC was pedestrian. He netted 82 yards on 15 carries against Houston, and then we held him to 70 on 18 attempts, which was just above the aforementioned average. The hit by Pollard and the subsequent lost fumble were huge. We were up by 8, they turned it over in their own territory and we followed up with a TD. I'd personally state that he took him out instead of shutting him down, however, that's semantics on my end. We were in the led and we did force them into turnovers on the next three drives, so it's difficult to state that we outright fail to reach the SuperBowl without that play. But that doesn't take away from the fact that Pollard was a solid starter who helped set the aggressive tone, albeit as the most penalized safety in the league. It's fair to argue whether we reach the SuperBowl without him, but that's a sentiment that would hold true for multiple players.
That being said, if we're pointing out specific performances, we were ran all over in the SuperBowl. With as much as the focus fell on Lewis being whipped in the passing game, Pollard himself was nothing short of a liability in coverage, with multiple mind-boggling bites in zone coverage. Not to mention the missed tackle on the Crabtree TD. In many ways, the final victory alone came in spite of Pollard. Would Pollard have been a solid starter for us the following year? I don't see why not, especially since he played to the same standard in Tennessee. However, would he have been a better presence than what Ihedigbo was the following season? That's difficult to argue. I agree that we lost defensive leadership in 2013, mostly in the losses of Reed and Lewis. But as far as losing the edge because of Pollard, that's highly debatable. Ihedigbo was a machine in around the LOS in 2013. He was one of our best tone setters and he continuously flew around the ball, noted by the fact that he had the highest run stop percentage in the league. Even Webb referred to him as the "captain back there." I thought that at worst, he replaced the value of Pollard in intensity, performance, and locker room leadership in equal measure. That's just my opinion though. In either case, in terms of assigning blame for the inability to neither repeat nor reach the postseason, I am somewhat puzzled by the focus on the following year's defense that categorical improved over the offense that was unquestionably abysmal.
Good post, I won't touch on all of it as it is as you say "semantics" but I'm just reminding everybody that he's one big reason why we have a second title, we had a handful of season saving plays that postseason and the one we always talk about is the Hail Mary to Jacoby Jones... but if Pollard hadn't murked Ridley the season would have ended there as well. It's also fair to say that Harbaugh had some great coaching moments and was responsible for the development of most of the team, both Pollard and Harbaugh wouldn't have a ring without the other.