Yeah I hear you. If we picked Penning it would be deflating but he'd honestly be quite a versatile guy as you said. Definitely has the chance to play LG right away. Could play LT of need be. Could be the swing T. If you take Penning you probably can rest easy with your OL. You just didn't get the opportunity to add a stud on D.
i should clarify given that we're only 3 days away now and that penning seems to very much be clearly in play but...
i do not think penning is a bad prospect, in fact i think he's a very good prospect, i just dont see him as a top 15 type prospect and prefer a load of guys to him
but he has some high level traits and qualities that would be exciting as well as that positional versatility upside where he'd be a great fit at guard (albeit we'd hopefully be drafting him with the intention that he would be playing tackle in the future) - ive seen some who think he'd be a dominant guard and i definitely see that upside given that his question-marks/weaknesses as a pass protector would be somewhat mitigated by a move inside
the other disappointing thing about drafting penning is it likely means we'd be giving up on 2 3rd round picks in the previous 2 drafts too at LG