I'm afraid I have to disagree. I'm not saying we had star-studded rosters, but we had some solid team talent more than capable of making and winning in the playoffs. Many people rag on the 2013 draft because of Elam and Brown, but we also pulled pro bowlers in Jensen, Juice, and Williams. The loss of Ray was not a big deal since he was tapped anyways. I also thought Jameel McClain filled in nicely. We def sucked at WR that year. Just missed the playoffs
I'm curious why you think 2014 was an overachievement. There was some serious talent on that team with one of the greatest pass-rushing duos of all time in Suggs and Dumervill, a really great O coordinator, good Oline, and SSS bringing the energy with a 1k season.
Screw 2015: That was indeed an IR meltdown.
2016 was another talented team that started 3-0. Joe really regressed that year with all his back foot lob balls, but we were still more than capable of being a playoff team. Weddle helped solidify a suspect secondary. Just missed the playoffs
2017 I agree we lacked any real talent on offense. The defense was solid, though. Pretty sure we were top 5 in points allowed. Z Smith and Judon came into their own that year. We were playoff bound, and then 4th and 12 happened.
2018-2020 were massive disappointments. I try to be glass half full, but we went 35-13 in the regular season. Clearly, we had talented teams but went 1-3 in the playoffs. That's concerning. We love to ignore it on this forum, but it's still a disturbing trend that this TEAM hasn't shown up in the playoffs. It's not a Lamar problem either; it's a team problem.
So here's how I see it:
2013: you lost a ton of players from 2012 (Ray, Ed, Birk, Ellerbe, Kruger, Cary Williams, Boldin)
You make a great trade for Dumervil, but the FAs you did sign, like Spears, Huff, and Canty, were either bad or unspectacular. That was also the end of the McKinnie experiment and the beginning of the Monroe one, of which neither worked out well.
The three guys you referenced (Juice, Jensen and BWill) literally had no impact whatsoever on the 2013 Ravens, because they barely played. Jensen I believe ended up on the PS, Williams played about 10% of all defensive snaps that year, and Juice played 4 offensive snaps total, because Leach was still there.
Our Tackle and Center play was combos of McKinnie/Monroe, Oher, and Gino Gradkowski. Even Rick Wagner didn't play much in that season. AQ Shipley was like the top reserve. We had KO and Yanda but that's it.
I don't need to walk through the pathetic nature of our pass catchers.
Defense was average, offense had no playmakers and couldn't pass protect.
2014: overachieved mostly because of injuries and missed games.
Will Hill was suspended for six games
Monroe missed like 6 games and part of the playoffs
Pitta played 3 games
Jimmy Smith missed last 10 games + playoffs
Rick Wager missed last 3 games + playoffs
Asa Jackson, who was actually important that year, missed 12 games + playoffs.
By end of the year, the offensive line was in shambles and we had no depth in the secondary. And it showed. We were lucky to make it as far as we did.
2016 I'll concede was probably a better roster than I thought, but yeah, Joe sucked.
I give 2018 sort of a pass, mostly because you're transitioning mid-season to a new QB with gigantically different skills sets, and we probably don't make the playoffs at all without that change.