So, I'm going to reply to both of you on this one and I think Sledge alluded to this a bit...
I know Maclin, Wallace, Woodhead, etc. aren't top tier weapons. They aren't S or A tier. They're like B tier and maybe Watson and Allen are like C+. But the thing is, even with these guys injured, Joe hasn't looked any different.
Maclin and Wallace are out? He'll look the same throwing to Camp and Moore. Everyone is healthy? He'll still have 5.5 YPA and a touchdown and interception.
He just hasn't shown even remotely consistent mechanics or accuracy and I don't think it matters who he's throwing the ball to unless they can make otherworldly plays on the regular.
Joe has amazing ability and capabilities, but he's just not showing any of it and hasn't been since 2014.