UPennChem
Hall of Famer
I agree with basically all of this. I'm not sure there is actual pessimism on Wolfe. I mean maybe he's lying but didn't the guy tweet a little while ago he is ready to go when people were saying he might retire? Even if he's not a quote unquote starter he helps the rotation a ton. Also Pierce should be significantly better than BWill. You get Campbell back, Madabuike has another year under his belt and you add Jones. At the beginning of the offseason that was a really weak unit. Now as you said it is solid.I don't know that Dline is dramatically better. For starters, I have no clue if Wolfe is going to play, but there's a lot of pessimism there, and I'm not sure he's a game changer anyway. We added Jones, who I like, but that's about it. Pierce may be an upgrade over Williams, but it's not a big one in my eyes. I don't think its a weak unit, but I don't think we've made dramatic shifts in pass rush ability from that group.
The depth at Corner is a major concern for me. I'm fine with playing more 3 safety looks, but literally any injury to Marlon or Peters is a big problem right now. Stephens is basically your 3rd corner, who I wouldn't trust to play outside much at this stage, and you've got a rookie 4th rounder as your #4. Last year, if everybody were healthy, you had Tavon and Averett as your #3 and #4 Corners. That's a huge step back in my opinion.
I'm hedging my bets on pass rush. A lot of optimism for Ojabo, but I have zero expectation he starts the season, and I expect he lands on PUP. I think you get any contribution from him like post-bye-week, and it'll be a success. And remember, that's basically with no offseason. I can't see him suiting up for training camp or the preseason at all.
For me, its simple... we traded depth at Corner and strength at WR for a significantly upgraded Oline and Safety position.
The good news is, if you focus on where we struggled last year, it was a) running the ball without using the QB and being a more balanced offense and b) giving up big plays in the passing game. I think our personnel decisions would hopefully address both of those.
But I don't think our passing game will be nearly as good, I think we may struggle to stretch the ball down field, and I have concerns about pass rush. I think our defense may have a lot more of a "bend but don't break" mentality, especially early in the year. I think teams will be able to move the ball on us, but hopefully limited in terms of scoring.
Corner depth kinda sucks. It needs a veteran. Fortunately this can be remedied.
WR depth is fine but it's missing a starter. This may or may not be able to be remedied effectively.
EDGE is gonna get back Houston and Hayes. Then Ojabo will come back in November. Should be largely the same if not potentially better come the end of the season. Oweh will continue to improve.
So as you said, our run D should be better and our starting secondary will be much better. Those things should help out the pass rush hopefully long enough to get Ojabo in there whether that be this year or next.
Really you've just gotta be nervous about losing Marlon, Marcus, or Bateman to injury. Because those position groups as constructed right now can't afford those injuries. Every other position group actually has the depth to take blows.